Thursday, 09 January 2014 21:50by Ummar Zia |
From Viewpoint Online, a Marxist journal based in Pakistan
This is enemy territory. Get what you want, roared Lt. General Niazi on his first day in Dhaka after he assumed command from Lt. General Tikka Khan in 9171. The supplementary part of the report presented by Hamood-ur-Rehman Commission states:
after the military action the Bengalis were made aliens in their own homeland. The life, property, and honour of even the most highly placed among them were not safe. People were picked up from their homes on suspicion and dispatched to Bangladesh, a term used to describe summary executions
The report also noted that all Bengalis were treated as enemies, even the loyalties of officers who served in the Army were viewed with suspicion and their arrests were ordered without taking their superiors or Government of East Pakistan on board. Bangladesh Authorities alleged Pakistanis killed three million, sparing none, and raped 200,000 of Bengali women. Pakistan disputed the figures while conceding to excesses of a few who were duly punished. The Hamood-ur-Rehman Commission with no plausible explanation to the contrary; rebuffed the claims of Bengalis as fantastic and fanciful . Indeed the blessed were those who departed and the wretched survived all but statistics for us.
How many people do you have to kill before you qualify to be described as a mass murderer and a war criminal? asked Harold Pinter in his Noble Lecture. Never mind our sloppy obsession with numbers, they can never convey harrowing tales of Dhaka. And there is only so much we know about it because the report has been shelved by Pakistan authorities for decades- except the supplementary part leaked to our friends across the iron border.
The response in Pakistan on the execution of Abdul Quader Molla was outrageous. Tributes were paid from all over the country. The National Assembly passed resolution expressing concern and condolences over the execution of Molla for his loyalty to Pakistan. One wonders how Adam Smith ™s impartial spectator would have reacted to our theatrics. The impartial spectator from a distance; immuned from vested interests, parochial values and social conditioning, would have broadened the localize events and might asked us: how would we feel if the verdict of our apex court triggered such outcry in another country?
Our reaction had nothing to do with the issues of Prosecution or evidence nor did we fret about the opportune political scheduling of the case. It was only grounded in false, nay xenophobic, sense of history that continues to dominate our national psyche.
Our jingoistic patriotism once again trumped Bengali sensitivities. Instead we should have introspected and asked: why an active member of Pakistan Movement and the chief polling agent of Ms Fatima Jinnah became disillusioned. Sirs, it did not happen overnight. A steady accumulation of thousand slights, inflicted over a period of time, ensued in Mujib-ur-Rehman an anger and resentment; one shared by most if not all Bengalis, which led him and Bengalis adrift. Our antics on the streets and oddly naive resolution in the National Assembly only vindicated their struggle.
Berlusconi when he visited Benghazi in 2008 said: “It is my duty as a head of government, to express to you in the name of the Italian people our regret and apologies for the deep wounds that we have caused you [Libyans] . Apology, to the people of Bangladesh, for not just the war crimes but also the discriminatory policies right from the independence, might be far-fetched. But we must at the very least acknowledge the wrongs done in our brief and inglorious history. Its time we introduced Al-Shams and Al-Badr into our curricula. Our children should be taught about all the circumstances that led to the Fall of Dhaka.
Kenzaburo Oe, the famous Japanese writer, hoped his nation shall remain committed to idea of democracy and determination never to wage war again aided by an understanding of its own history of territorial invasion. In Pakistan we must develop such understanding from our history if we wish to avoid another tragic partition. Those who fail to learn from history, they say, are doomed to repeat it.
Details
Published on Sunday
13 February 2011 17:06
Written by Radical Socialist
WSF Declaration of the Social Movements Assembly
12 February 2011
As the Social Movements Assembly of the World...
Details
Published on Thursday
20 January 2011 01:43
Written by Radical Socialist
Whither Tunisia?
Curfew in Tunisia! What is the political significance?
January 13 by Fathi Chamkhi
Just hours after his...
Details
Published on Monday
28 February 2011 18:16
Written by Radical Socialist
Tunisia, Egypt: a revolutionary process of world scope
Fourth International
The International Committee of the Fourth International at...
Details
Published on Wednesday
15 April 2020 18:48
Written by Radical Socialist
by K Mann
The demographic data collected and reported in the media for sickness and mortality rates...
Details
Published on Thursday
08 July 2010 04:46
Written by Radical Socialist
Eric Toussaint
During the 2007 constitutional referendum, one might have thought that the party created by Hugo...
Details
Published on Thursday
02 June 2016 16:59
Written by Radical Socialist
NORTH OF IRELAND
What does the success of People before Profit candidates mean?
by John McAnulty
The election of...
Details
Published on Friday
06 December 2013 09:00
Written by Radical Socialist
Nelson Mandela 1918-2013
Tom Bramble | 06-Dec-2013
The death of Nelson Mandela closes the life of a heroic...
Details
Published on Monday
20 September 2010 05:30
Written by Radical Socialist
The Path of Naxalbari: An Appraisal
Kunal Chattopadhyay
In this essay, the discussion will remain mostly confined to...
Details
Published on Friday
08 July 2011 16:03
Written by Radical Socialist
PSM women hit, told to drink toilet bowl water, change clothes in front of men
Wong Choon...
Details
Published on Wednesday
19 October 2011 11:36
Written by Radical Socialist
15th October 2011: a great victory for the outraged
Éric Toussaint
Since February 2003, this is the first...
Details
Published on Thursday
20 January 2011 01:43
Written by Radical Socialist
Whither Tunisia?
Curfew in Tunisia! What is the political significance?
January 13 by Fathi Chamkhi
Just hours after his...