Home Gender The right to choose. Socialism and women's rights in Ireland

The right to choose. Socialism and women’s rights in Ireland

Details
Published on Thursday
21 March 2013  17:15
Written by Radical Socialist
 

The right to choose. Socialism and women’s rights in Ireland

Socialist Democracy, Ireland

The death of Sativa Halappanavar after having been refused an abortion sparked a storm of protest and a renewed discussion of woman’s rights, occurring mainly within the ranks of United Left Alliance. The debate centred around a reformist perspective calling for legislation to rationalize and codify medical responsibility where a woman’s life is at risk, opposed by the demand that we call for a women’s right to choose. 

The reformist perspective was that politicians were under pressure and there was broad public support for limited reform. By joining in this call socialists could help win this reform and produce an environment conducive of further advances. 

The alternative view was that socialists were in principle in support of the right to choose and, that by striking when the iron is hot, they could swing popular opinion behind them. 

A sign of the coming demise of the ULA and its endemic electoralism and reformism came in a dishonest and mealy-mouthed ULA statement of December 16th. Listing a number of health issues it went on to say: 

“Many think that it should be up to a woman, in consultation with her doctor, to decide if she should continue with a pregnancy. We support all of these arguments – which give women the choice”. 

Health issues and consultations with doctors do not add up to the right to choose. The perspective that the ULA took was the reformist one. Events since then have shown how inadequate that perspective was. It fails to distinguish between public sentiment, mobilizations and the creation of a full-blown movement. It sees any reform as a permanent step forward, refusing to acknowledge that any rights under capitalism are subject to abolition as the needs of capital change. 

The initial mobilizations died away. The church, the virulent Catholic right-wing and forces within the governing Fine Gael party have all mobilized. Legislation will be brought forward but, rather than providing an environment for further advance, the discussion is about whether or not women should be allowed a “suicide clause” – that is whether the risk of suicide can be included as a threat to the life of the woman. 

The call for the right to choose has the advantage of bringing together the genuinely democratic forces in Irish society and giving them a programme around which they can unite. However this is not sufficient if it is linked to the idea that, if we strike while the iron is hot, we can win over public opinion. 

The feminist movement in Ireland has faced a strategic crisis for many years. In the ’60s and ’70s many feminists saw their movement as linked to the Republican and socialist movements. Their gradual decline saw a growth in belief in the modernisng influence of imperialism – especially that of Britain in the North and of Europe south of the border.   That belief has been eaten away as a modernizing facade has been replaced by an all-out assault designed to push workers’ rights to the levels of the 19th Century. 

The decay of capitalism means that levels of democracy and of individual rights will constantly be eaten away and that democratic movements that operate only within the con-fines of capitalism are bound to be disappointed. 

The members of Socialist Democracy believe that socialists should stand foursquare behind the call for a woman’s right to choose. We do not oppose partial reform, will gladly work with anyone fighting for this and will welcome any gains. 

For ourselves however, we consistently call for the right of women to choose and call for feminists to join in the fight for a socialist republic. We do this, not because it is a short cut to victory, but because without these principles the journey has not yet begun.
 

RELATED ARTICLES

Selling Sexual Services: A Socialist Feminist Perspective

Details Published on Saturday 07 February 2015 09:43 Written by Radical Socialist

REVOLUTION WILL BE FEMINIST OR IT WON’T BE

Details Published on Monday 20 June 2011 11:26 Written by Radical Socialist

Proletarian Socialism and Women’s Liberation

Details Published on Tuesday 13 October 2009 05:41 Written by Radical Socialist

Most Popular

Lula III: a new hope

Details Published on Friday 04 November 2022 15:56 Written by Radical Socialist Sao Paulo, October 30th. By Carlos N. Socio-environmentalist of the São Paulo Insurgency Today, October 30, 2022, at...

From Occupy Wall Street to Occupy America

Details Published on Sunday 16 October 2011 08:35 Written by Radical Socialist http://www.internationalviewpoint.org/spip.php?article2323 From Occupy Wall Street to Occupy America The emergence of a mass movement Dan La Botz   A handful of...

Class Independence and the Broad Parties: A Response to Left Voice

Details Published on Sunday 01 January 2023 09:20Written by Radical Socialist

Ailing king, wise soul and the kingdom of Pakistan

Details Published on Wednesday 22 June 2011 00:54 Written by Radical Socialist Ailing king, wise soul and the kingdom of Pakistan by Amjad Nazeer The unpleasant outcomes of our low priorities...

The Greek general strike of 19 and 20 October

Details Published on Wednesday 02 november 2011 15:29 Written by Radical Socialist The Greek general strike of 19 and 20 October (by Pandelis Afthinos and Andreas Kloke) The 48-hour political...

Radical Socialist Statement on Manipur

Details Published on Saturday 22 July 2023 04:37 Written by Radical Socialist

On basic principles regarding the war in Ukraine and Socialist Action (US)

Details Published on Thursday 07 July 2022 12:05Written by Radical Socialist

Interview with Gilbert Achcar on anti-Muslim video and political rights

Details Published on Sunday 30 September 2012 04:39 Written by Radical Socialist Anyone incensed by symbolic violence, such as the video in the US or cartoons in France,...

In Defense of Permanent Revolution

Details Published on Tuesday 21 September 2010 18:01 Written by Radical Socialist Ernest Mandel In Defense of Permanent Revolution A Reply to Doug Jenness Written: 12 December, 1982 Source: Intercontinental Press, August 8,...

Syria and the Need for International Solidarity

Details Published on Friday 11 December 2015 05:00 Written by Radical Socialist SYRIA Response to Tariq Ali 2015, or the need for internationalist solidarity Wednesday 2 December 2015, by Joseph...